Goat Milk vs Cow Milk: 10 Key Differences & Health Benefits

Goat milk is gaining popularity as more people discover its unique benefits. But how does it really compare to cow milk? This comprehensive guide breaks down the nutritional differences, digestibility factors, and potential health benefits to help you decide if goat milk is right for you.

Nutritional Comparison

Macronutrients per Cup (8 oz)

Nutrient	Goat Milk	Cow Milk (Whole)
Calories	168	149
Protein	9g	8g
Fat	10g	8g
Carbs	11g	12g
Sugar	11g	12g

Key Vitamins and Minerals

Nutrient	Goat Milk	Cow Milk	Winner
Calcium	327mg (25% DV)	276mg (21% DV)	Goat
Phosphorus	271mg (22% DV)	222mg (18% DV)	Goat
Potassium	498mg (11% DV)	322mg (7% DV)	Goat
Vitamin A	483 IU (10% DV)	395 IU (8% DV)	Goat
Vitamin B12	0.17mcg (3% DV)	1.1mcg (18% DV)	Cow
Riboflavin	0.34mg (20% DV)	0.45mg (26% DV)	Cow

10 Key Differences Between Goat and Cow Milk

1. Digestibility

Goat milk is easier to digest for many people.

Why?

• Smaller fat globules: Goat milk fat globules are about 1/5 the size of cow milk
• Softer curd: Forms a softer, smaller curd in the stomach
• Faster digestion: Moves through digestive system more quickly

This matters if you experience:

• Bloating after drinking cow milk
• Stomach discomfort
• General digestive issues

2. Fat Composition

Goat milk has a different fat structure.

Fat Type	Goat Milk	Cow Milk
Medium-chain fatty acids	Higher	Lower
Short-chain fatty acids	Higher	Lower
Long-chain fatty acids	Lower	Higher

Benefits of MCFAs:

• Absorbed more directly
• Provide quick energy
• May support metabolism
• Don’t require bile salts for digestion

3. Protein Structure

Different proteins, different reactions.

Protein	Goat Milk	Cow Milk
A2 beta-casein	Primary	Varies by breed
A1 beta-casein	Very low	Common
Alpha-s1 casein	Lower	Higher

Why this matters:

• A1 casein linked to digestive discomfort in some studies
• Alpha-s1 casein most allergenic component
• Goat milk may be tolerated by some with mild cow milk sensitivity

Important: Goat milk is NOT safe for those with true milk allergies.

4. Lactose Content

Similar lactose levels, but…

Both milks contain approximately 4.5% lactose. However, some lactose-intolerant individuals report tolerating goat milk better.

Possible explanations:

• Faster digestion = less time for fermentation
• Overall easier digestibility
• Placebo effect in some cases

Note: Goat milk is not lactose-free and is not recommended for severe lactose intolerance.

5. Taste and Flavor

Goat milk has a distinctive taste.

Fresh goat milk characteristics:

• Slightly sweet
• Clean finish
• Mild flavor when properly handled

What causes “goaty” flavor?

• Capric, caprylic, and caproic acids
• Buck proximity during milking
• Poor handling or storage
• Diet of the goats

Getting good-tasting goat milk:

• Buy from quality farms
• Ensure proper chilling immediately after milking
• Keep buck separate from milking does
• Store in glass containers

6. Cream and Butter

Goat milk cream doesn’t separate naturally.

Property	Goat Milk	Cow Milk
Cream separation	Minimal	Rises quickly
Naturally homogenized	Yes	No
Butter making	More difficult	Easy

Implications:

• Goat milk stays naturally mixed
• Great for drinking, but harder for butter
• Special equipment needed for cream/butter

7. Cheese Making

Both milks make excellent cheese, with differences.

Cheese Property	Goat Cheese	Cow Cheese
Yield	Lower (less casein)	Higher
Flavor	Tangy, distinct	Milder
Texture	Often softer	Varies
Popular types	Chevre, feta	Cheddar, mozzarella

Goat cheese benefits:

• Lower lactose (whey drains off)
• Distinctive flavor
• Often easier to digest

8. Allergy Considerations

Goat milk is NOT hypoallergenic.

Consideration	Details
Cow milk allergy	About 90% also react to goat milk
Cross-reactivity	High between goat and cow proteins
Sheep milk	Similar cross-reactivity

May help with:

• Mild cow milk sensitivity (not true allergy)
• A1 casein intolerance specifically
• General digestive discomfort

Will NOT help with:

• True milk protein allergy
• Severe lactose intolerance

9. For Babies and Children

Important considerations for pediatric use.

Age Group	Recommendation
Under 1 year	Neither as primary milk (use formula or breast milk)
1-2 years	Consult pediatrician before switching
2+ years	Either can be appropriate

Concerns with goat milk for infants:

• Lower folic acid than cow milk
• Lower vitamin B12
• Not a complete infant nutrition source

Benefits for older children:

• May be gentler on sensitive stomachs
• Good calcium source
• Palatable to many kids

10. Cost and Availability

Goat milk is typically more expensive.

Factor	Goat Milk	Cow Milk
Store price	$8-12/gallon	$3-5/gallon
Farm direct	$6-10/gallon	$4-8/gallon
Availability	Limited	Widespread
Organic options	Growing	Common

Why goat milk costs more:

• Lower production per animal
• Smaller farms, less economy of scale
• Niche market
• Shorter shelf life

Health Benefits of Goat Milk

Potential Benefits

1. Digestive Comfort

   • Easier on sensitive stomachs
   • Faster digestion
   • May reduce bloating

2. Nutrient Absorption

   • Better mineral bioavailability
   • Higher absorption rates reported

3. Skin Health

   • Used in lotions and soaps
   • pH closer to skin’s natural pH
   • Moisturizing fatty acids

4. Bone Health

   • High calcium content
   • Good phosphorus levels
   • Vitamin D in fortified versions

What Research Shows

Established findings:

• Different protein structure from cow milk
• Smaller fat globules confirmed
• Higher certain vitamins and minerals

Needs more research:

• Long-term health benefits
• Specific disease prevention
• Optimal populations for consumption

Choosing Between Goat and Cow Milk

Consider Goat Milk If You:

• Experience digestive discomfort with cow milk
• Want to try something different
• Are interested in making cheese
• Have access to quality fresh goat milk
• Don’t have a dairy allergy

Stick with Cow Milk If You:

• Have no digestive issues with cow milk
• Budget is a primary concern
• Need wide availability
• Prefer the taste
• Need higher B12 content

Try Both If You:

• Are curious about the differences
• Want variety in your diet
• Are exploring dairy options
• Want to compare for yourself

How to Start Drinking Goat Milk

Finding Quality Goat Milk

1. Farm direct: Best freshness and quality
2. Farmers markets: Meet the farmer
3. Health food stores: Reliable brands
4. Grocery stores: Growing availability

Tips for First-Timers

• Start with fresh (not UHT/shelf-stable)
• Try from a reputable dairy farm
• Keep well-chilled
• Use within 5-7 days
• Try in coffee or smoothies first

Raising Your Own Dairy Goats

If you’re considering producing your own goat milk, these breeds are best for dairy:

Breed	Milk Production	Butterfat
Saanen	Highest	3-4%
Alpine	High	3-4%
Nubian	Moderate	5-6%
Nigerian Dwarf	Lower volume	6-10%
LaMancha	High	4-5%

Find dairy goat breeders →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is goat milk healthier than cow milk? “Healthier” depends on individual needs. Goat milk offers easier digestibility and different nutrient profiles, but both can be part of a healthy diet.

Can I give my baby goat milk? Not as a primary milk source before age 1. Always consult your pediatrician for infant nutrition decisions.

Why does some goat milk taste bad? “Goaty” taste usually indicates poor handling, buck proximity, or old milk. Fresh, properly handled goat milk tastes mild and sweet.

Is goat milk good for lactose intolerance? Goat milk contains lactose similar to cow milk. Some people tolerate it better due to easier digestion, but it’s not lactose-free.

Can I make butter from goat milk? Yes, but it’s more difficult because the cream doesn’t separate naturally. You’ll need a cream separator.

Conclusion

Goat milk offers a viable alternative to cow milk with some distinct advantages, particularly for digestibility. While not a solution for true dairy allergies, many people find goat milk easier on their stomachs. The higher price point is offset by unique nutritional properties and uses.

The best way to know if goat milk is right for you? Try it yourself with fresh, quality milk from a reputable source.

Interested in dairy goats for your farm? Browse our breeder directory to find dairy goat breeders near you.

---

Want to raise your own dairy goats? Read our Nigerian Dwarf goat guide or complete guide to starting a goat farm.